Hello Subscription independently researches and reviews the best subscriptions and products. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.

Mystery Tackle Box Reviews

Updated June 10, 2024

Mystery Tackle Box

Mystery Tackle Box is a monthly subscription box service featuring new fishing products delivered straight to your doorstep. Once you subscribe, every month you will receive a variety of quality fishing products chosen by fishing experts. When you sign up, you can even choose which species of fish you are wanting to catch. You can cancel at any time and shipping is free!

$19
99 per month
Notification

Subscribing to Mystery Tackle Box

Subscribing to Mystery Tackle Box is easy! Simply swim on over to the Mystery Tackle Box website and hit the Get Started button to subscribe. Choose your plan and species and add it to your cart. Enter your email and then check out with your shipping and billing information and you are all set! Your first box will ship within 10 business days. 

How Mystery Tackle Box Works

Mystery Tackle Box is a monthly subscription box service that delivers the newest fishing lures and tackles in a box straight to you. It is a fun and affordable way to discover new products with advice on the best way to use them. Items are from both large and small manufacturers and are up to 40% off retail prices!

When you sign up for the Mystery Tackle Box you can choose from 3 plans: Regular, Pro or Elite. Next you choose the species of fish that you are after. For the regular plan the choices are Bass, Inshore Saltwater, Panfish & Trout or Walleye. Pro species choices are Bass, Multi-Species, Inshore Saltwater, Panfish & Trout or Walleye. Elite plans can choose from Bass, Multi-Species or Inshore Saltwater. There is also a seasonal Ice Fishing option. 

You can choose from monthly, 3-month, 6-month or 12-month plans. The longer plan that you choose, the cheaper that your monthly box is per box. Shipping is always free and you can pause or cancel at any time.

Mystery Tackle Box Pricing and Options

Regular plans start at $19.99 a month. A 3 month plan is $56.97, a 6 month plan is $107.94 and a 12 month plan is $119.88 which is an overall savings of 40%. Pro plans start at $29.99 for a monthly plan. A 3 month pro plan is $86.97, a 6 month pro plan is $164.94 and a 12 month plan is $179. Elite plans start at $39.99 a month for a monthly plan. Elite 3 month plans are $119.97, 6 month plans are $227.94 and a 12 month elite plan is the best deal at $240 which is 46% off the monthly plan. 

What Comes in Each Mystery Tackle Box?

That depends on your plan! Each box contains an assortment of lures and bait for whichever species you are fishing for. The Regular plan contains at least $25 of gear in each box. The Pro box has at least $40 of value in each box. The Elite plan contains $60 of items. And when you pre-pay for multi-month plans you get the best deals for the lowest price. 

Mystery Tackle Box Benefits and Drawbacks

Mystery Tackle Box Benefits

  • You get to try new fishing gear every month at 40% off retail prices
  • With 3 affordable plans, you can customize which species of fish you want to go for
  • Shipping is free
  • Great for both beginners and experts!

Mystery Tackle Box Drawbacks

  • Lures in the boxes aren’t for every species of fish you might want to catch
  • You may not want or need everything in the box
  • You can’t add items or buy products individually 

Is Mystery Tackle Box Worth It?

Considering most anglers spend up to $50 a month on fishing gear, the money spent on Mystery Tackle Box is definitely worth it if you are into fishing. Not only will you have access to new quality gear, at a fraction of the price of individual lures and bait, you get specific instructions and tips on how to use the latest and greatest equipment in the fishing industry. Plus with free shipping, Mystery Tackle Box is definitely with a try. The best deal is the Elite 12 month plan, which would also make a great gift for the fisherperson in your life!

If you are trying to grow your tackle box then Mystery Tackle Box is definitely worth it. With over a hundred different brands in their boxes, you are sure to find something new you haven’t heard of before or something that you’ve been wanting to try. 

Mystery Tackle Box Tips

When you subscribe to Mystery Tackle Box, you get exclusive access to fishing tips from the pros. The inbox magazine has detailed information on what is in the box as well as topics like lure depth and the best time of the day to catch certain species of tips. There are also a ton of how-to videos and blog posts to help you land that fish!

Once you subscribe, you can easily change your box type, as well as species preference. Just log in to your account and from the dashboard just click on the switch button for a list of options. Easy!

Got an angler in your life who is hard to buy for? Why not get them a gift subscription to Mystery Tackle Box? Buying fishing gifts can be hard if you don’t know exactly what to get. Plus fisher people can be particular about what kind of gear they like to use. With a gift to Mystery Tackle Box they can choose their own subscription and species according to their fishing style. Plus they will think of how awesome you are every time they get their monthly box in the mail!

How Mystery Tackle Box Compares to Other Fishing Subscription Boxes

Mystery Tackle Box versus Monsterbass

Monsterbass is a monthly fishing subscription box membership that specializes in bass fishing. The professional anglers at Monsterbass select lures and baits that come in each box depending on where you live and how you like to fish. You are able to provide feedback on what comes in each box so that they can hone in on perfecting your next box.

Mystery Tackle Box is another monthly fishing subscription box that doesn’t only just focus on bass fishing. They ship out over 2 million baits a year and are one of the original fishing box subscription companies.

The obvious difference between the 2 is that Mosterbass focuses 100% on bass fishing. They offer 2 plans; the Regional Pro Series and the National Series. The Regional Pro Series is a little more expensive than the National Series but lets you choose your bass box based on where you live. The choices are Midwest and the Great Lakes, Northeast Region, Pacific Southwest, Southern Region and Northwest and Mountain Region.

Mystery Tackle Box on the other hand has 3 subscription plans; Regular, Pro and Elite and you can choose which kind of species you are fishing for such as Bass, Inshore Saltwater, Panfish & Trout or Walleye.

The other main difference is the cost for each monthly box. Monsterbass subscriptions start at $25 for the National Series Plan and $35 for the Regional Pro Series. Mystery Tackle Box pricing is lower at $19.99 for their Regular box, $29.99 for their Pro box and $39.99 for their Elite Box. Both companies offer discounts when you prepay for multiple months of boxes.

So which is the better subscription box service? That depends on what you are looking for. If you are a bass fisherman and know that you want to focus on this alone, then Monsterbass is probably the subscription box for you. If you are a beginning angler or not quite sure what you are wanting to catch or maybe an advanced angler who wants to diversify your tackle box, then Mystery Tackle Box is your best bet.

 

 

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does Mystery Tackle Box cost?

There are 3 pricing plans. Regular plans start at $19.99 a month. Pro plans start at $29.99 for a monthly plan. Elite plans start at $39.99 a month for a monthly plan. You can choose to prepay for either 3, 6 or 12 months for additional savings.

What is the sign up process process for Mystery Tackle Box? 

Hop on over to the Mystery Tackle Box website and hit the Get Started button to subscribe. Choose your plan and species and add it to your cart. Enter your email, shipping and billing information and you are subscribed. Within 7 business days, your first box will arrive at your doorstep.

What types of payment does Mystery Tackle Box accept?

Mystery Tackle Box  accepts credit/debit cards including VISA, Mastercard, Amex and Discover. PayPal is another option for payment. 

How do I cancel my Mystery Tackle Box subscription?

If you want to cancel your subscription, simply log into your account and scroll to the bottom of your active subscriptions. From there you can choose to pause or cancel. When you cancel you won’t be billed any further, but you will receive boxes you have already pre-paid for. 

What size are the products in the Mystery Tackle Box?

Boxes contain a mix of full size baits and some sample packages of other tackle. This allows anglers to get more variety in each box and try out new products.

Can I choose which species I am trying to catch when I subscribe to Mystery Tackle Box?

Absolutely! Each plan gives you choices of species including trout, bass and more. There is even a seasonal option for ice fishing in the winter.

How difficult is it to change my subscription type to Mystery Tackle Box?

It’s easy. Just log into your account and go to your dashboard. Click on the Switch button next to your current species to change your subscription options. Make sure you do this before the last day of the month so it will be on your new settings for your next shipment.

Does Mystery Tackle Box offer exchanges or refunds on box items?

No. There are no returns or exchanges on monthly subscription box items and all sales are final on the boxes.

Are there any other perks to Mystery Tackle Box membership besides the monthly boxes?

Yes. With a subscription to Mystery Tackle Box you get exclusive access to fishing tips from the pros. There is an inbox that describes how to use the products in the box, as well as online videos and blog posts to help you improve your fishing skills. 

Once I place my order, when will my first Mystery Tackle Box ship?

Once you subscribe, your first box will ship within 10 days.

Is there a parent or affiliate company to Mystery Tackle Box?

Yes, Mystery Tackle Box is a subsidiary of Karl’s Club which is an online retailer of fishing gear that offers a separate club where you can save up to 30% off site-wide and get access to new gear and member-only products, as well as other perks.

How much does shipping cost?

Shipping to the US and Canada  is free. 

Is every Mystery Tackle Box the same?

No. There are multiple variations in monthly boxes and you will never receive the same item twice.

Is there a way to get my products featured in a Mystery Tackle Box?

Yes. Mystery Tackle Box works with both large and small bait and tackle manufacturers. For more information about getting your product listed on the Mystery Tackle Box website, send an email to [email protected].

Does Mystery Tackle Box offer any gift options?

Yes. Mystery Tackle Box offers gift certificates so that the angler in your life can choose their own subscription and species. 

How do I redeem a gift certificate for the Mystery Tackle Box?

Gift certificates can be redeemed at any time to activate a gift subscription. Simply create an account, enter your gift certificate code. Enter your shipping and registration information and you’re all set!

What if I have a problem with my order?

You can email the customer service team at Mystery Tackle Box at [email protected]

0/5 (0 Reviews)