Hello Subscription independently researches and reviews the best subscriptions and products. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.
HandPicked Beauty Box Reviews
Updated June 13, 2025
HandPicked Beauty Box
The box will contain 5 full-size products, with a total value of up to $150. If you subscribe, you will begin a journey to discover some of the wonderful beauty products that exist. Some you may already know and love, others you will be pleased to discover!
$39
99 per month
This subscription is currently inactive.
I’m subscribed to a lot of beauty boxes, all of which deliver 5-6 SAMPLES with occasional small full sized items. It’s fun to try new things, but annoying when the samples only last a week. This subscription box is more expensive than say Ipsy or Sephora Play!, but you get what you pay for, that’s for sure! Handpicked has 5 FULL SIZED beauty products in every box worth up to $165! So unlike sample boxes, where you can’t really put a value on products intended to be free, with Handpicked, if I get 5 products worth $130, I actually HAVE 5 products worth $130, many of which will last for months. I’ve received 2 boxes so far and have LOVED all the high end beauty products I’ve got thus far, and use a majority of them every day still! The curator of this box, Alexia, has an awesome sense of beauty products and what people like. I can’t recommend this enough!
Handpicked Beauty box has been a pleasant surprise. I have been receiving subscription boxes for more than two years and this has been one of the best curated boxes debuts I have seen. Box included full size , great quality and beautiful colors products. Pacifica mineral eye shadows are beautiful and known for its natural ingredients. Manna Kadar bronzer is always. A great addition. Tarte, Stila and Josie Maran, are other of the well known brands included and the products are very useful for you or for a beautiful gift. Certainly, this box at least double its cost and I recommend it. Disclosure: I have received a special editor rate for my review, but it does not affect my objective view.
As a long-time beauty writer (since 2000) , I have seen lots of product trends and brands. The latest trend that seems to “have legs” is the subscription box trend. While some boxes have folded or disappoint more than they “wow” you, I think I have found a curated subscription box that takes itself SERIOUSLY. HandPicked Beauty Box is very thorough in what is included in the box and it is sure to please. The box is as shown and the products are brands that any woman who has read a beauty magazine would recognize like Pacifica (known for fragrances and great natural color cosmetics), Josie Maran(– a brand created by a super-model which is focused on natural beauty products,, Stila (celebrity favorite brand), Tarte (another natural ingredient color line that is also a celeb fave) and cult favorite- Manna Kadar! These products pretty much provide you with items you would need for day to day or day to night beauty choices. Each product is FULL SIZE– so you won’t feel shortchanged in this process. The total on this collection of products at retail is double the cost of this box. These are all brand new products. Some are carried on their own websites, others can be found at Sephora or Ulta stores. Even if you bought this box in order to get stocking stuffers or individual gifts for friends, it’s a great array of name-brand products that also you are getting for less than retail! That’s my idea of a #MUSTBUY product. Try it out. I am sure you won’t be disappointed.
#Disclosure: I bought this product at a discount so that I could review it. The discount enables me to do the review. It has zero impact on my ability to be impartial and fair.
I loved this box! I love that most all of the beauty product were FULL-SIZED! The value is definitely there. All the products included were from well-known and high-end beauty brands. I was totally satisfied with my first box and I can’t wait for my next box.