Hello Subscription independently researches and reviews the best subscriptions and products. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.

Firstleaf Reviews

Updated November 1, 2023


The Firstleaf Wine Club is a subscription wine club where experts custom curate your wine selection shipments by starting with a personal wine taste preference quiz. You can choose the frequency of your shipments with plan options from 1, 2 or 3 months. Based on your membership, you will get 6 bottles of wine shipped directly to you whenever you like

94 per month

Get your first 6 wines for only $44.95, plus FREE shipping! Deal applies automatically, just visit and subscribe.


Subscribing to Firstleaf Wine Club

Subscribing to Firstleaf Wine Club is a piece of cake. Hope on over to their website and start by taking Firstleaf’s wine preference quiz. Once you complete the quiz, enter your email for your results. From there you check out and can get $100 off your first 3 shipments. Enter your shipping and billing information, review your order and your first shipment will be on its way to you soon!

How Firstleaf Wine Club Works

Firstleaf memberships start with a wine preference quiz. Choices are red, white or a mix. Next, you choose how sweet you like your wine; Unsweet, a Little Sweet or Sweet. Then there are a series of questions about specific types of wine. You get to pick Thumbs Up, Thumbs Down or I’m Not Sure. Wine types are Oaky California Chardonnay, Napa Cabernet Sauvignon, Argentinian Malbec, Australian Shiraz, Italian Pinot Grigio, Sweet Riesling, Bordeaux Red, New Zealand Savignon Blanc and Sweet Red Blends.

Next up on the wine quiz is a question about how adventurous you are when trying new wines. Choices are Cautious, A Little or Adventurous. You then get to choose where you are on your wine journey; Beginning, In Between or Expert. Then you pick what you think about specific brands of wine types including Robert Mondavi Cabernet Sauvignon, Prisoner Red Blend, Flowers Chardonnay, Layer Cake Shiraz, Jordan Cabernet Sauvignon, Chateau Ste. Michelle Riesling, Menage a Trois California Red, Yellow Tail Pinot Grigio and Barefoot Moscato.

Then on to the food choices for wine pairings to help hone in on your taste profile. You are asked a series of questions about Almonds, Mushrooms, Key Lime Pie, Buttered Toast, Green Olives, Black Coffee, Tart Lemonade, Pina Coladas and Caramel Frappuccinos. Then comes flavors;  Oak, Floral, Citrus, Mineral, Fruit, Crisp, Tannic and Acidic. 

Finally, you pick how many bottles you drink a month. The choices are <2, 3-4 or 5+. The last question is about your opinion on Rose and then , your results are calculated. This highly personalized quiz helps determine your curated bottles and less than 2% of people get the exact same results. 

Examples of What May be in Your Firstleaf Wine Club Shipment:

  • Cartesian- 2020 Sauvignon Blanc from California
  • Três Tigres Triste- NV Vinho Blanco from Portugal
  • Sirenia- 2020 Airen from Spain
  • Winter Fox- 2018 Syrah from California
  • The Perfect No. 6- 2020 60% Shiraz- 40% Cabernet Sauvignon from Sonoma 
  • Merce Carme- 2020 Tempranillo from Spain

Firstleaf Wine Club Pricing and Options

It’s free to join the Firstleaf Wine Club. Once you are a member, you get an introductory price with $40 off your first shipment and free shipping. The next 2 orders you get $30 off shipments. Once the introductory offers have been used, the cost per shipments is $89.94 plus $14.95 shipping and tax. Want to double your order? The cost for 12 bottles is $179.88 with free shipping.

Firstleaf Wine Club Benefits and Drawbacks

Firstleaf Wine Club Benefits

  • The wine quiz helps Firstleaf understand your wine preferences and each shipment is truly customized based on the results of your quiz
  • With Firstleaf Wine Club’s introductory offer you get $100 off your first 3 orders plus free shipping on your first order
  • You get to pick the frequency of your shipments

Firstleaf Wine Club Drawbacks

  • You may not love all the bottles in your shipment but Firstleaf Wine Club will credit you for a bottle if you aren’t happy with it
  • After the introductory offer, the price increases and shipping is not free

Is The Firstleaf Wine Club Worth It?

When you join Firstleaf Wine Club you get an introductory offer of $100 off your first 3 shipments with free shipping on your first order. From there, the price does increase, but if you love wine, it is still a great deal! For less than $100 you can get 6 bottles of  premium wine shipped directly to your doorstep. And when you double your order and you get an even lower price with free shipping! So is Firstleaf Wine Club worth it? You betcha grapes on it!

Firstleaf Wine Club Tips

Firstleaf Wine Club wants to get your selections just right for you! Their detailed wine quiz is one of the most extensive of any wine club membership and less than 2% of members have the exact same results. After you receive your shipments, you can rate each wine in the shipment so Firstleaf Wine Club can improve with future shipments. 

Loved some of the bottles in your customized shipment and want to order more? When you are a member of Firstleaf Wine Club, you get access to their online wine shop with 60% off of retail prices. With membership, you can shop in their wine store at any time to get this amazing discount.

Along with their customized wine quiz, what makes Firstleaf Wine Club different is their flexibility. You can choose the frequency of your shipments for every 1, 2 or 3 months based on your needs. Got a big party coming up? Why not double your monthly shipping for 12 bottles at a great price!

When you join Firstleaf Wine Club you get exclusive access to their on-call concierge service. This team of wine experts is there to help you with wine recommendations and food pairings. All free of charge and included in your membership.

Have a friend or relative who loves wine? Send them a referral code to join and you receive $40 in credit and your friend receives an additional $40 off their introductory offer. Win win! Firstleaf Wine Club also offers digital gift cards with a personalized message. 

If you are unsure about joining, why not try the introductory offer. You can cancel or pause at any time with no commitment.

How The First Leaf Wine Club Compares to Other Wine Subscription Memberships

Firstleaf Wine Club versus Wine Accesses The Decanter Club

The Wine Access Decanter Club is a seasonal subscription wine membership featuring 6 bottles of wine delivered 4 times a year. Curated by wine experts at Wine Access and Decanter Magazine, you can get the top-rated critic choice bottles delivered straight to your doorstep. 

The Decanter Club from Wine Access has a more expensive price point. Their Everyday Excellence Club starts $180 a shipment and their more exclusive Rare Luxuries Club starts at  $475 a shipment. Shipping is free with both options. With Firstleaf Wine Club, you also get 6 bottles of wine and shipments cost $89.94 plus $14.95 shipping after their introductory offer.

The main difference between FirstLeaf and Wine Access Decanter Club is the wine curation. With The Decanter Club you get the best wines selected by a panel of experts and Decanter magazine who taste over 20,000 bottles of wine a year. FirstLeaf also has wine experts, but they are not as esteemed. The wines at Wine Access The Decanter Club tends to be more exclusive than the everyday wines at FirstLeaf, yet you are going to pay a lot more than with Firstleaf Wine Club.

FirstLeaf is more flexible as far as shipment frequency than Wine Access The Decanter Club. With Firstleaf Wine Access you get to choose how often you want shipments from 1, 2 or every 3 months. Also, you get more control over what kinds and brands of wine will be in your shipments based on the results of your wine preference quiz whereas with Wine Access The Decanter Club your bottles are curated by experts. You can leave feedback about your shipments with both clubs and both offer return credit if you are unhappy with one of your bottles.

So which is the better Wine Club subscription? Both are great deals on wines so it really depends on your wine needs and budget. The Decanter Club curation tends to offer more sophisticated, rare wines. FirstLeaf is an affordable way to try all different types of wine to hone in on your particular palette and especially helpful for the novice wine drinker.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a subscription to Firstleaf Wine Club cost?

It’s free to join the Firstleaf Wine Club. Once you are a member, you get an introductory price with $100 off your first 3 shipments. Once the introductory offers have been used, the cost per shipment is $89.94 plus $14.95 shipping and tax.You can also double your order for12 bottles at a cost of $179.88 with free shipping. 

What comes in each Firstleaf Wine Club shipment?

Each shipment includes 6 bottles of wine customized on the results of your wine preference quiz. You can rate the bottles in your shipment to help the curators at Firstleaf Wine Club choose bottles for your next shipment. 

How often will shipments arrive from Firstleaf Wine Club?

You get to choose the frequency of shipments from either 1, 2 or every 3 months. 

What is the sign up process for The Firstleaf Wine Club? 

Simply head over to Firstleaf and start by taking their wine quiz. Once you receive your results, you enter your shipping and payment information and just like that, you’re a member!

Do I need to be a member of Firstleaf Wine Club to order wine from their online shop?

No. You don’t have to be a member to order wine but as a member you get up to 60% off of retail prices.

Does Firstleaf Wine Club offer exchanges or returns?

Unfortunately there are no returns, but if you have a problem with any bottle in your order, Firstleaf Wine Club will credit you with the price of the bottle for your next order.

What types of payment does Firstleaf Wine Club accept?

Firstleaf Wine Club  accepts credit/debit cards including VISA, MasterCard, Amex and Discover.

Where does Firstleaf Wine Club ship?

Firstleaf Wine Club ships to the US only and most states depending on individual state laws. More details can be found on the website under FAQs. 

How much does shipping cost?

Shipping on your first shipment is free! After that shipping on subsequent orders is $14.95. When you double your order. Shipping is free. 

How can I be sure that my wine from Firstleaf Wine Club will arrive in good condition?

The experts at Firstleaf Wine Club ship your bottles with a climate controlled process the moment it leaves the winery. 

Do I have to have an adult sign for my shipment?

Yes. Federal law requires shipments only be released to those over age 21.

Are there other perks to joining Firstleaf Wine Club besides the wine shipments?

Yes. In addition to the wine shipments, Firstleaf Wine Club members get 60% off in Firstleaf’s online store. As a member you also get free access to the expert Firstleaf Wine Concierge Team who can help you find the perfect bottles.

What Firstleaf Wine Club gift options are there? 

Firstleaf offers digital gift cards with a personalized message. The default amount is $80 which covers one shipment of 6 bottles of wine. You can change the amount from $25 up to $700.

Does Firstleaf Wine Club offer a referral program? 

Yes. You can request a referral code to share with friends to join the club. You receive $40 in credit and your friend receives an additional $40 off their introductory offer. 

Can I pause or cancel my membership at any time?

Absolutely, as long as your current shipment is not yet in transit. 

What if I have a problem with my Firstleaf Wine Club order?

Contact customer service at [email protected] or call 1-800-461-7203. They are more than happy to help!

0/5 (0 Reviews)