Hello Subscription independently researches and reviews the best subscriptions and products. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.
Blind Tiger Record Club Reviews
Updated August 23, 2025
Blind Tiger Record Club
Get curated vinyl delivered each month from the music style you choose. Pick from Alternative, Rock, and Singer/Songwriter.
$35
00 per month
I wanted to like this one, especially with the demise of VMP, which was quite good until it wasn’t (the last year or so), so gave this record club a try. 1st thing to know – this club curates records, but they do not have their own special variants or pressings, meaning you can get the same records elsewhere (and cheaper). The selection was interesting, with several genres to choose from and the ability to switch back and forth among the records at will. Unfortunately, both of the records I received were delivered damaged due to poor packaging – they use very cheap, expandable mailers that do not hold the records securely, causing seam splits and other damage during shipment. While this is always a risk when ordering online, I have very rarely had this issue with other retailers. Unfortunately, this falls under their “cosmetic damage” clause in their return policy, so not eligible for a refund. I wrote to them to share my experience and did not even receive the courtesy of a reply. Steer away from this one – you can get the same records elsewhere for less, and they are much more likely to arrive in one piece…
I really liked the idea of this company but they have a lot of flaws in their website. I received the wrong record two months in a row. I changed my style to receive an album I actually wanted and for two months they sent me the wrong one. I also updated my new address three times and they shipped it to the wrong address. Great idea here but they need a lot of work.
I love it! Great record selections, great customer service, and the supporting podcast they do for their records of the month is great too! The process of how the club works is very transparent and I definitely recommend giving it a try!
While fairly new to the subscription, I have had a wonderful experience with Blind Tiger Record Club even through some USPS troubles.
I purchased several other records along with the subscription service (Paid upfront for 12 months because you save a few bucks). To get free shipping, I had the additional purchased records ship with the subscription that ships at the end of each month. The end of June comes and goes, I get my shipping confirmation email. Several days go by, and shipping is stuck on “Pre-Shipment.” I hate to be that person that contacts CS for trivial things, so I wait it out, there is a global pandemic after all. It gets to be July 13 and still no package, mind you I live in Nashville so it should have arrived a day maybe 2 days after they shipped. At this point, I have no choice, the package may be lost and I don’t want to be out 700+ dollars, not to mention some of the records purchased were sold out at this point so they likely wouldn’t be able to replace them. A man named Rudy responds and tells me he dropped it off personally and he will look into it and assured me he will make it right. Already relieved at this point because I can tell that he cares about the issue and is really trying to fix the issue vs some sellers who are unresponsive or would just say it’s not their responsibility after it ships. A few days go by and I notice that the tracking updates and I can tell that the package will arrive after all. Rudy was able to save my lost package. He did so in a very professional and kind way, I really can’t even be mad because it wasn’t even his fault USPS lost it. However, he made sure I was taken care of!
Stay away! Music selection is good, that’s where they got me. The website and ordering process is a clown show. Never complained about the way a site it set up or works before until I came across Blind Tiger. I believe they had the BT set the site up to save a few bucks… really bad idea.
Wonderful box with great choices of vinyl
I ordered a record from this company last month and have yet to receive it. I have contacted them multiple times with no response or explanation. Don’t waste your time or money. I have never seen such poor customer service.