On Demand
Bake Me A Wish Alternatives
Remember the excitement you felt as a child when your birthday cake was carried into the room? They want to help recreate that excitement and experience for your friends, clients, or loved ones' special day with their delicious gourmet food gifts.
Their cakes are made with only the finest, freshest ingredients by award-winning New York bakeries. Over the past decade, they've grown to offer more and more of the finest bakery gifts available, including gourmet cookies, brownies, cupcakes, pies, and quiches.
Also, they donate 5% of every order to BMAW Cares, a goodwill program that makes contributions where they matter most.
What’s the subscription that’s most like Bake Me A Wish? See our list of Bake Me A Wish alternatives and discover the box that’s your best match!
Bake Me A Wish Alternatives
Discover the most relevant boxes!
Tokyo Treat
Every month we’ll send you a mystery box stuffed to the brim with over two pounds of premium, full-sized candies straight from Japan. Treats in […]
Levain Bakery
Sweet, savory and perfectly balanced, these cookies satisfy cravings for peanut butter and chocolate lovers. Semi-sweet chocolate cookie dough is packed with soft, smooth peanut […]
Mix Box by Homemade Bakers
Mix Box is a classically delicious - 100% homemade dessert baking box. The easy, step by step instructions, in combination with pre-measured ingredients, makes for […]
Cheryl’s Cookies Buttercream Frosted Cookie of the Month
Don't let the cookie jar go empty! Instead have a box of our unparalleled buttercream frosted cut-out cookies delivered right to your (or one of […]
Amazing Clubs Chocolate of the Month Club
Each month, they'll deliver a new and delicious variety of premium, hand-crafted chocolates shipped fresh from some of the country's most renowned chocolatiers and made with […]
Sakuraco
We source and deliver Japanese tea, sweets and snacks from local makers for you to enjoy. Take a unique snack journey around Japan with us.
Hotel Chocolat Tasting Club
Hotel Chocolat Tasting Club is a monthly chocolate subscription box. Cocoa is the number one ingredient with no artificial additives. Expert chocolatiers invent new recipes […]
Cheryl’s Cookies Gourmet Cookie of the Month
A tasty box of cookies is automatically delivered to your door 6 or 12 times a year – you choose! Each delivery includes 12 individually […]
Cheryl’s Cookies Gourmet Brownie of the Month
A tasty box of brownies is automatically delivered to your door 6 or 12 times a year – you choose! Each delivery includes 10 individually […]
Amazing Clubs Cupcake of the Month Club
Fall in love with cupcakes all over again! Each month, you'll unwrap 12 of the finest gourmet cupcakes America has to offer in four delicious […]
Japan Candy Box
Every month Japan Candy box will send you a box filled with a carefully selected mix of quirky Japanese sweets & snacks. Each box will include […]
Bake Eat Love Box
Bake Eat Love is a baking kit delivering easy-to-follow recipes and all the delicious pre-measured, non-perishable ingredients needed to bake desserts of all kinds at […]
Amazing Clubs Pie of the Month Club
Each month, they'll deliver a delicious, fresh-baked, gourmet pie in a perfectly flakey golden crust. Their selections are hand-crafted from the freshest ingredients using traditional […]
Amazing Clubs Cheesecake of the Month Club
Gift recipients receive a new variety of all-natural, gourmet cheesecake every month from specialty bakeries nationwide! Every order includes Free Shipping, free gift announcement and […]
Amazing Clubs Cookie of the Month Club
Each month, they'll deliver a new selection of delicious, fresh-baked, gourmet cookies baked with only premium, all-natural ingredients and carefully chosen by their taste-testing professionals […]
The Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club
Each month, The Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club features the hand-crafted signature chocolate creations of a world-class chocolatier. Our selections are based on quality, […]
Amazing Clubs Ice Cream of the Month Club
Each month, they'll deliver four different, one-pint varieties of premium, gourmet ice creams hand-packed and shipped dairy-fresh to arrive just days after they've been made. […]
Amazing Clubs Cake of the Month Club
Each month, they'll deliver a new selection of delicious, gourmet cakes baked with the freshest, all-natural ingredients and carefully chosen by their taste-testing professionals who […]
Harry & David Chocolate Club
Enjoy exquisite gourmet chocolates and chocolate gifts year-round with our Chocolate-of-the-Month Club Collection. From tried-and-true favorites like our signature chocolate cherries to innovative treats like […]
Amazing Clubs Dessert of the Month Club
Gift recipients receive a new variety of gourmet dessert every month from award-winning bakeries nationwide! Every order Includes Free Shipping, free gift announcement and our […]
Wolferman’s Bakery Favorites Club
With monthly arrivals of decadent bakery delights, you can look forward to a new delivery of delicious treats every month. Their Bakery Favorites Club delivers […]
zChocolat
zChocolat is an online retailer of chocolate gifts, which lets you send luxurious chocolate boxes to anyone in the world. They offer personal VIP memberships […]
Great Clubs Chocolate of the Month Club
For more than 24 years we have been delivering creamy, premium chocolate to our Chocolate of the Month Club members that are hand-dipped in small […]
Ethel M Chocolates
Each month, our Chief Chocolatier will curate a special mix of premium, Ethel M Chocolate pieces to fill an exclusive Chocolate of the Month Box. […]
Goldbelly Pie Subscription
Gift The Greatest Pie Subscription Ever. Seriously. You know your dad, BFF, bae, neighbor (who you’re trying to butter up before your infamous New Year’s […]
Goldbelly Cookie Subscription
Gift The Greatest Cookie Subscription Ever. Seriously. You know your dad, BFF, bae, neighbor (who you’re trying to butter up before your infamous New Year’s […]
Crumble Crate
Become a baking enthusiast and #elevateyourbake Each box provides you with all the tools & techniques necessary to create gourmet treats in your kitchen. You […]
Oomph! Sweets
Oomph! believes you should be able to expect more from your candy: More flavor, more functionality—more of everything good! That's why they're using science to […]
