Curated Subscription
Replacements for The One Crime Mystery
Do you like crime shows on TV and puzzles? If the answer is yes, then this box is for you! Become special agent Davis and help solve puzzles to receive additional information about the cases and get to the final answer.
$23
75 per quarter
Missing The One Crime Mystery? What’s the subscription that’s most like The One Crime Mystery? See our list of The One Crime Mystery replacements and say hello to a new subscription!
Replacements for The One Crime Mystery
Discover the most relevant boxes!
Hunt A Killer
Love to solve crimes? Believe that you have what it takes to become a top-notch detective? Then Hunt A Killer might just be exactly what […]
The Deadbolt Mystery Society
The Deadbolt Mystery Society is a monthly subscription box service for lovers of mystery and suspense. Each month, a new mystery box filled with puzzles, […]
Dispatch by Breakout Games
Murder, romance, scandal—this story has it all. Once you open your delivery, you’ll find yourself entangled in the strange disappearance of your closest childhood friend, […]
ParaBox
Who doesn't love a good ghost story, or a story about those strange lights in the sky. Our shirts will cover a wide range of […]
Finders Seekers Mysteries
Finders Seekers is the box subscription that takes you on a wondrous hunt each month. We are an exclusive group of adventurers and intellectuals who […]
The Resystance by Madmen & Heroes
Join us if you yearn to disentangle mysteries, puzzles, ciphers and all matters of confounding and mystifying enigmas. Each month, we will submit to you […]
The Conundrum Box
Your Adventure Awaits… Get a monthly adventure shipped right to your door! Part Escape room, part choose your own adventure, wind your way through fun […]
Dispatch Kids by Breakout Games
Developed by the makers of Breakout Games, Dispatch Kids challenges children ages 3-5 to learn their way, designing their own adventure through hands-on problem-solving in […]
CosyKiller
CosyKiller is an annual murder mystery subscription box delivered directly to your door. Each box is packed with vintage memorabilia, keepsakes and intrigue. Each story […]
Brain Chase
Each month you’ll unlock a new Escape Room adventure. Your subscription includes decoder tools, hidden clues, and a login to an online Dashboard where you'll […]
A Killing Affair
Once you have selected your subscription plan A.K.A.'s Criminal Investigation Division will ship your 1st episode. All players start with A Killing Affair's Independence Day […]
ForensiKit by Crime Scene
Learn about forensic science and methods. Go hands-on with techniques like fingerprinting, collecting shoe prints, and more. Use the same tools the pros use to […]
Cryptic Case by Escape Rooms Monthly
Immerse yourself in our creative, original storylines. Become one of the characters as you make your way through various journeys. Games have incorporated AR technology […]
Be the Detective
Immerse yourself in a new, realistic mystery that unravels over three months. Each month, you will receive a new episode and you're the detective! Analyze […]
Killer Mystery
Do you enjoy a good whodunnit? Do you love solving games and puzzles? Do you get lost in a great mystery book or movie? Do […]
Murder & Co
Murder & Co. is a crime-solving subscription box game that mixes storytelling, puzzle-solving, and code-cracking, with curated gifts that often act as evidence. Each story […]
Masters of Mystery
Masters of Mystery are here to provide you with the ultimate mystery games - hosted by you - either at the venue of your choice […]
Murder Mystery Box
Murder Mystery Box is a quarterly adventure box wherein you are presented with a curious box. Your adventure shall follow the trail to solve a […]
Chilling Screams
Chilling Screams has to be played to be understood Combining audio, video, puzzles and physical evidence sent to you every month, it's like a horror […]
Gruzzle A Puzzling Company
Gruzzle sends challenging mysteries to qualified mystery solvers, people with a knack for thinking outside the subscription box. Every other month, Gruzzlers will receive a […]
Murder Mystery Quilt
In the Murder Mystery Quilt, you'll follow along in the story as Kitty gets closer to catching the killer--and before the solution is revealed, your […]
Cryptid Crate
Cryptid Crate is a monthly subscription box filled with various cryptozoology and paranormal themed items to wear, display and collect. Expect a carefully curated box […]
Mail Order Mystery
We deliver mysterious experiences for kids through the mail! Your child receives letters & objects in the mail from the characters in a mystery. Imagine […]
Escape the Crate
Love escape rooms? We ship escape room adventures straight to your door. Work with your family and friends to crack codes, solve riddles, and discover […]
Mystery Experiences Company
Become part of the story! We provide immersive mystery experiences that begin through the mail with mysterious letters and notes, newspaper clippings, historical documents, artifacts […]
Escape Room Geeks
Transform any place into a thrilling escape room! Just download these ready-to-play escape room kits, get your kids together, and be the host of your […]
