Hello Subscription independently researches and reviews the best subscriptions and products. Things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.

Sizzlefish Reviews

Updated December 28, 2022

Sizzlefish

Sizzlefish sends the finest quality, sustainable seafood in perfectly portioned sizes direct to you. Subscribe to enjoy easy, delicious meals in no time. You can customize your box with whatever kind of seafood you like, from expertly cut slices of Ahi Tuna to Maryland Crab Cakes. Plus, you get all the health benefits that come with a diet rich in fish like better brain function and improved heart health.

$111
86 every week
Notification

Subscribing to Sizzlefish

The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) says that nine out of ten Americans aren’t getting their recommended amount of seafood. That means most Americans aren’t taking advantage of the research-proven health benefits of seafood like reducing the risk of heart attack and improving mental health. It’s recommended that you consume eight ounces of seafood every week. So, are you getting the health benefits of eating seafood?

If you’re not, you probably have good reasons. Most fresh seafood needs to be used immediately, and the quality of fresh seafood at the grocery store is often questionable. Sizzlefish solves this problem: with fast, free shipping and a 100% satisfaction guarantee, you can start eating more delicious seafood on a regular basis. Sizzlefish’s frozen seafood maintains its fresh flavor while allowing you to store it for longer.

When you subscribe, you get a choice of fifteen different types of seafood to choose from, including favorites like Alaskan Salmon, Wild Gulf Shrimp, Chilean Sea Bass, and Soft Shell Crab. Sizzlefish has more than 30 years of experience in the seafood industry and uses only the highest-quality products. Additionally, Sizzlefish has a commitment to sustainable practices, which is particularly important to maintain the health of our oceans.

How a Sizzlefish Subscription Works

Every month, Sizzlefish will deliver a box of vacuum-packed individual portions or packs directly to your home. Sizzlefish offers three different boxes to choose from:

  • Prime Box: Includes 14 or 28 portions in each box of sustainably caught fish and shellfish. When you select this plan, you can build your own box with items like Sea Scallops, Wild Gulf Shrimp, Thai Curry Salmon, and more.
  • Wild Seafood Favorites: This box includes 10 to 14 portions of natural wild-caught fish and shellfish. A new menu is curated monthly with this plan.
  • Prime Plus Box: This plan includes the largest selection of sustainable seafood and delivers 14 or 28 portions each month. Choose this plan for a wide range of options from Rainbow Trout to Mahi-Mahi.

Note that each portion is 4 to 6 ounces. The seafood arrives frozen and should be transferred directly to your freezer. You’re able to pause or cancel your subscription at any time.

Not sure how to prepare all your seafood? Luckily, Sizzlefish provides a wide range of recipes. You can browse through recipes by type of seafood–like tuna, walleye, crab, etc.–or check out their Featured Seafood Recipes section. From Linguine with Clams to Baked Chilean Sea Bass with Fresh Corn Salad, they have plenty of options so that you can make the most out of each delivery. Check out all of Sizzlefish’s recipes here.

How Much Does a Sizzlefish Subscription Cost?

You can tailor your Sizzlefish subscription depending on how much and what kind of seafood you want each month. Every Sizzlefish subscription comes with free shipping for U.S. customers. Below is the cost for each plan:

  • Prime Box: $125.86 for each shipment for 14 portions ($8.99 per portion); $223.72 per shipment for 28 portions ($7.99 per portion)
  • Wild Seafood Favorites: $119.95 per shipment of 10 to 14 portions ($8.57 to $11.99 per portion)
  • Prime Plus: $139.86 per shipment for 14 portions ($9.99 per portion); $251.72 per shipment for 28 portions ($8.99 per portion)

Use this link to subscribe to Sizzlefish and get a discount on your first box!

Pros & Cons of a Sizzlefish Subscription

Pros

  • Large variety: Sizzlefish always offers a wide array of different types of seafood, from shrimp and scallops to tuna, trout, and much more. This means you’ll never get tired of eating the same kind of seafood.
  • Excellent quality, appropriate portions: Reviewers praise the high quality of Sizzlefish’s products. Though the seafood arrives frozen, once it’s thawed and prepared, you’ll never notice the difference. It also comes in appropriately sized portions, meaning you’ll have enough for a meal but not too much. Sure, you could go to a grocery store and find inexpensive seafood, but with Sizzlefish you know that you’re getting a tasty product that’s sourced sustainably.
  • Health benefits: Research has long demonstrated the benefits of a diet that’s rich in seafood. From protecting cardiovascular health to strengthening muscle endurance and improving vision, consuming seafood regularly has clear benefits. A Sizzlefish subscription ensures that you’re eating the right amount of fish and shellfish to obtain these health benefits.
  • Excellent packaging: Transporting and delivering fish can be challenging. Fortunately, Sizzlefish has decades of experience in the business. Dry ice and styrofoam are used to ensure that you have clean, dry seafood on delivery. This means that even if the package is left on your doorstep for hours, the seafood will still be good.
  • Convenience: No more running to the store to buy fish and being unsure which is best. Instead, seafood is delivered directly to you with specific directions on how to thaw the seafood properly.
  • Outstanding customer service: Reviewers noted that customer service is prompt to respond to any questions and concerns. Deliveries are typically fast and smooth. When anything goes wrong, Sizzlefish makes it easy to connect with their customer care team.

Cons

  • While Sizzlefish does what it can to keep costs in check, it is still relatively expensive. Choosing to subscribe means you’re investing in your health and in sustainable seafood practices.
  • Sizzlefish’s seafood will arrive at your house frozen. While Sizzlefish argues that its products lose none of their flavor, some people are set on only having fresh seafood. If you only like fresh seafood, then Sizzlefish isn’t for you.

What’s in a Sizzlefish Box?

This all depends on which of the three boxes you choose. The Wild Seafood Favorites Box includes wild-caught seafood with new recipes and menus curated each month.

The Prime subscription gives you a selection of seafood to choose from including:

  • Crab Cakes
  • Wild Gulf Shrimp
  • Thai Curry Salmon
  • Atlantic Cod
  • Haddock
  • Rainbow Trout
  • Sea Scallops
  • Korean BBQ Salmon
  • Coho Salmon
  • Sockeye Salmon

The Prime Plus subscription gives you even more variety. You get everything included in the Prime plan plus:

  • Red Snapper
  • King Salmon
  • Rockfish
  • Halibut
  • Sablefish
  • Walleye
  • Tuna
  • Mahi-Mahi

What Do Customers Think of Sizzlefish?

Sizzlefish receives a 4.9-star rating on ShopperApproved. More than 90% of reviewers gave it 5 stars. On Facebook, Sizzlefish receives a 4-star rating. Customers give Sizzlefish high marks for having excellent customer service, a smooth order process, and, most importantly, tasty seafood.

Is Sizzlefish Worth It?

If you’re looking for pure, natural seafood delivered directly to your door, then Sizzlefish has plenty to offer. With a wide range of delicious options, from salmon to shellfish and more, you can customize a box to your tastes. You get all the benefits of a healthy diet while enjoying high-quality, sustainable seafood.

Ready to start your subscription? Click here for a coupon on your first box!

Frequently Asked Questions

How Does Sizzlefish Compare to Wild Alaskan Company?

Wild Alaskan Company is also a subscription service offering seafood from sustainably managed fisheries. Wild Alaskan Company offers three different boxes focused on fish like sockeye salmon, cod, halibut, and rockfish.

Where Sizzlefish is different is that they also have shellfish like shrimp, scallops, and crab. Wild Alaskan Company is somewhat more expensive as well, with boxes starting at $145 per shipment.

How Does Sizzlefish Compare to Maine Lobster Now?

Another company offering seafood delivery service is Maine Lobster Now. As you might expect, this company specializes in a wide range of lobster, from lobster mac ‘n’ cheese to lobster tails, lobster rolls, and more. They ship lobsters across the country.

If you want a subscription service that delivers seafood direct to your doorstep, then Sizzlefish is the right choice. If you can’t get enough lobster, then you’ll want to select Maine Lobster Now.

How Can I Cancel a Sizzlefish Subscription?

Sizzlefish allows you to skip up to seven orders at a time, which gives you flexibility. That said, if you do still want to cancel, you can contact customer service at [email protected] or call (833) 603-0888. Sizzlefish cannot guarantee refunds for any orders that have already been processed.

How Do I Skip Sizzlefish Deliveries?

As mentioned, you can skip up to seven shipments at a time. There are no penalty fees and you don’t have to cancel your subscription.

To skip a delivery, sign in to your account and select the manage subscriptions option. Then click on the subscription you’d like to edit and select which orders you’d like to skip.

How Are Sizzlefish Orders Packed?

In the seafood delivery business, good packing practices are essential. That’s why Sizzlefish uses reusable, recyclable coolers that contain dry ice. Individual portions and packs in the cooler are all vacuum packed and your items should arrive hard-frozen. All you need to do is move them to the freezer.

What Are Sizzlefish’s Shipping Policies?

Sizzlefish offers free shipping for all orders over $100, meaning that subscribers always receive free shipping. Boxes are shipped via FedEx or UPS Ground except for the West Coast, which uses either UPS or FedEx Express two- or three-day transit.

Once your package is shipped, it will take one to three days to arrive. Sizzlefish does not ship during weekends because the extra shipping time extends beyond the effectiveness of dry ice.

Are Sizzlefish Products Farm-Raised or Wild-Caught?

Most of the fish are wild-caught with a few exceptions. (Sizzlefish does offer packages for those who only want wild-caught fish, including the Wild Ocean Blend.) When Sizzlefish does use farm-raised fish, they work with suppliers who are environmentally friendly and do not use antibiotics, farm chemicals, or pesticides.

Why Does Sizzlefish Send Fish Frozen Instead of Fresh?

Many people prefer fresh fish and shellfish. After all, nothing beats going fishing yourself and enjoying the catch of the day. A few days later, the fish or shellfish will lose their flavor and eventually go bad.

That said, Sizzlefish uses flash-freezing to keep its seafood good for longer. Basically, this process allows them to maintain a fresh state for months on end so that when you thaw and cook it, the fish will still taste excellent.

Sizzlefish notes that so-called “fresh” fish at the grocery store is typically already at least a week old or was previously frozen. Sizzlefish flash-freezes its products to ensure that you get the best experience possible with a delivery service.

What Is Sizzlefish’s Return and Exchange Policy?

Sizzlefish aims for customers to be completely satisfied with its products. If you receive seafood that’s damaged or has other problems, Sizzlefish will replace your order free of charge. All you need to do is contact [email protected] providing details of the problem within seven days of receiving the products. If possible, attach a photo to the email. Sizzlefish cannot accept perishable good returns, so do not send the purchase back to them.

Can I Buy Sizzlefish Products Without a Subscription?

Yes. Simply go to the Sizzlefish store to order whatever you’d like, from wild Alaska sockeye salmon to Maryland jumbo lump crab cakes. This provides a way to try their products without committing to a subscription. Keep in mind that you will get a better rate by subscribing to Sizzlefish.

Is Sizzlefish Right for Me?

For those of us who love seafood, what could be better than a box arriving on your doorstep packed to the brim with top-quality fish, crab, shrimp, and more? Sizzlefish offers a convenient and enjoyable way to eat healthier.

To start your subscription, check out this link for a great deal on your first box! 

0/5 (0 Reviews)