Replacements for NightShade's Cellar Box
This is a subscription box for anyone who loves the macabre, spooky, cute, gothic essence, and creepily cute. Each monthly box has a different macabre theme. For example, they have had Vampires, Spooky Horror T.V. shows, Carnival of Darkness, and Galaxy. Each box contains 6-15 items depending on which tier of a box you choose. They offer 3-4 tiers each month -- first tier contains 5 items (there is also a $27 box with 5 items, plus a clothing or deluxe item); the second tier contains 7+ items; the third tier includes 10+ items; and the final tier contains all previous items, plus a few extras.
Each box features bath products such as bath bombs, shower gel, body sprays, face masks, body butter, bath melts, bath salts, and shower steamers. Other products they include are keychains, pins, art prints, clothing, makeup, candy, candles, and wax melts. They are an independent beauty shop and team up each month with Etsy shops and other independent small businesses. They love all things beauty and spooky, so they looked to have the two in one box.
$20
00 every other monthships monthly
Missing NightShade's Cellar Box? What’s the subscription that’s most like NightShade's Cellar Box? See our list of NightShade's Cellar Box replacements and say hello to a new subscription!
Replacements for NightShade's Cellar Box
Discover the most relevant boxes!
Ipsy Glam Bag
IPSY is a women’s monthly subscription beauty membership known as The Glam Bag and contains sample and/or full-size makeup and beauty products delivered straight to […]

Allure Beauty Box
Allure Beauty Box is a women’s monthly subscription box membership containing 6 or more fun beauty products, with at least 3 full-sized items. The products […]

BoxyCharm by Ipsy
Taking personalization to the next level, BoxyCharm by Ipsy includes 5 full-size beauty products worth up to $200 - including 2 guaranteed Power Picks from […]

Boxwalla Beauty
Boxwalla Skincare Subscription box is curated for the luxury-loving skincare enthusiast. In our skin care boxes, you will discover the most effective & innovative plant-based […]

Petit Vour
Get 4-5 hand-picked luxury vegan beauty & grooming samples every month to apply, blend, buff, lather, soak and spray. A great way for anyone interested […]

BeautyFIX
BeautyFIX is a monthly subscription box that features over $100 worth of beauty products, hand-selected by an elite team of beauty pros.

Vegancuts Beauty Box
A monthly discovery box where you’ll receive 4+ deluxe or full-size products, from unique cosmetics to luxurious skincare. Their expert Beauty Box curator vets each […]

nmnl
Enjoy a monthly beauty box containing 8-9 items of Korean and Japanese cosmetics + skincare. Japanese and Korean beauty items of the highest quality to […]

Madison Reed
Hair Color subscription! Long-lasting hair color packed with rich nutrients like keratin, argan oil and ginseng root extract. Your hair will feel stronger, shinier and […]

Walmart Beauty Box
Each new season brings different product needs and a reason to refresh your beauty cabinet. In your Walmart Beauty Box, you’ll find sample beauty products […]

So Susan Color Curate
Every month, get 4 So Susan cosmetics products: 3 makeup items and 2 bonus items, one of which is an accessory. Bags are available to […]

BomiBox Korean Beauty Box
Welcome to Bomi Box - your ultimate Korean Beauty Box and online store for all your Korean Beauty needs. Every month you'll receive a gorgeous […]

Icon Box
Think of it as your all-access pass to the most-coveted brands, hottest launches, and need-to-try products in beauty. Available as a quarterly upgrade for Ipsy […]

Laurel & Reed
Elevate your daily routine with a subscription to Laurel & Reed’s luxury-curated, cruelty-free and non-toxic beauty, wellness, and lifestyle box. Every month, you’ll receive 4-6 […]

eSalon Custom Hair Color
Get individually blended hair color crafted just for you by professional colorists, with personalized instructions for an easy at-home application. Each has an advanced formula […]

The Detox Box
Each month, you’ll get a box featuring one or more green beauty products from The Detox Market's selected brand of the month at a value […]

Nourish Beauty Box
Nourish Beauty Box is a monthly, cruelty-free, ingredient-conscious subscription box for beauty enthusiasts! Living well starts with loving yourself, and what better way to cultivate personal […]

Beachly Beauty Box
Beachly Beauty Box is a women’s seasonal surf subscription box membership containing all things beauty inspired by coastal living. Four times a year, members receive […]

Public Goods
A Public Goods membership gives you access to healthy and sustainable home essentials. Their personal care, home goods, groceries, vitamins, supplements, and more are vegan-friendly, […]

Bath Bevy
Bath lovers rejoice! Bath Bevy is the subscription box just for you. Subscribe and receive bath products so tantalizing they will pull you out of […]

Bath Bevy TUBLESS
No tub? Not into baths? No worries! Our NEW Tubless option includes all the same handmade bath and body goodness without a single item included […]

Sephora Favorites
Sephora Favorite Kits comes with multibranded sampler set of beauty products for every occasion.

Love Goodly
Every other month you'll receive 4-5 cruelty-free, natural, vegan products, including a mix of full size products and deluxe samples of nontoxic beauty and skincare, […]

How to Be a Redhead
Get ‘Redhead Friendly’ Approved Products Delivered To Your Door Every Month. The How to be a Redhead (H2BAR) team now works meticulously to find products […]

PinkSeoul Box
PinkSeoul Box is a customized (based on your skin type and area of focus), full-sized, curated bi-monthly Korean skincare and makeup subscription box with at least […]

Net-A-Porter
Hand-picked by experts, NET-A-PORTER's Beuty Kits includes products from our skincare, haircare, nail and makeup edit. Including everything from a rejuvenating face mask to glamorous […]

Macy’s Beauty Box
Each month you will receive five deluxe beauty samples, one bonus item, other beauty-related products, and a $5 beauty coupon exclusively for Beauty Box subscribers, […]

HUM Nutrition
Get unique nutritionist-designed blends of vitamins, herbs, and supplements designed to provide the ultimate beauty nutrition. Fill out a 3 minute health profile and a […]
